Archive for the ‘Giuliani-SCC’ category

Rudy shouldn’t be GOP’s choice – By George J. Marlin

October 8, 2009

This commentary I wrote, Marlin:  Rudy shouldn’t be GOP’s choice,  appears on the Long Island Business News web site.

Rudy Giuliani Embarrasses Roman Catholic Church at Pope’s St. Patrick’s Cathedral Mass – By George J. Marlin

April 20, 2008

When the thrice married Rudy Giuliani was asked after Pope Benedict’s St. Patrick’s Catholic Mass if, “he was uncomfortable with having broken the Church ban on the divorced and remarried receiving Communion,” Rudy Giuliani answered, “No.”

What arrogance!  In the presence of the Pope, Giuliani declares he is above the rules of the Roman Catholic Church.

Rudy Giuliani knows better – he was well trained in the basics of the Catholic faith at Bishop Loughlin High School and Manhattan College.  He knows that he is prohibited from receiving Communion because of his marital status.

There’s more:  Giuliani also knows his pro-abortion, pro-partial birth abortion, pro-funding of abortion stands separates him from the Roman Catholic Church.

Four years ago, Pope Benedict made the Church’s position crystal clear in the document he authored “Worthiness to Receive Holy Communion – General Principles.”  In that statement, then Cardinal Ratzinger succinctly described the obligations of lay Catholics and the “ministers of Holy Communion.”  Ratzinger described numerous situations when a priest would have no alternative but to deny communion, and he directed priests to meet privately with any Catholic who publicly supports abortion and euthanasia laws, and to offer instruction in Church teaching.  The pastor’s job is to inform the public servant “that he is not to present himself for Holy Communion until he brings to an end the objective situation of sin and warning him that he will otherwise be denied the Eucharist.”  Ratzinger also explained that a priest who denies communion is not judging the condition of the individual’s soul and “is reacting to the person’s public unworthiness to receive Holy Communion due to an objective situation of sin.”

The final question:  Why was Giuliani even invited to St. Patrick’s?  After all, the Pope’s Mass was specifically celebrated for the Catholic clergy and religious of the region – not politicians.

The answer:  Got me.

Why Giuliani Lost – By George J. Marlin

February 4, 2008

This ARTICLE appears on

Rudy Giuliani and Partial-Birth Abortion – By George J. Marlin

November 25, 2007

After reading last week’s posting, “Rudy Giuliani and the American Catholic Bishops,” several viewers claimed that Rudy Giuliani’s opposition to partial-birth abortion proves he is moving in the right direction on the life issue and may be worthy of Catholic support in the presidential election.

Giuliani’s flip-flop on partial-birth abortion is a sop to orthodox Catholics and Evangelical Christians.  With Giuliani’s long paper trail on the subject, it is difficult to believe his conversion is sincere. (more…)

Giuliani article published on

November 20, 2007’s Monday, November 19th posting has been published on under the heading “Giuliani’s Catholic Problem Won’t Go Away.”

Rudy Giuliani and the American Catholic Bishops – By George J. Marlin

November 19, 2007

At the conclusion of their Baltimore national conference, the American Catholic Bishops announced they adopted “Forming Consciences for Faithful Citizenship,” a statement of principles to guide Catholic voters in the 2008 presidential election.

No doubt Rudy Giuliani supporters are combing the document for loopholes that can be used to convince practicing Catholics that it’s okay to vote for “fellow Catholic” Giuliani despite his pro-abortion stand. (more…)

Rudy Giuliani: Life Long Liberal — Edited by George J. Marlin

November 11, 2007

Rudy Giuliani: Life Long Liberal, a forty-two page white paper, is now available on this blog.  It can be reviewed with this link, Giuliani-Life-Long-Liberal, as well as under the heading of Giuliani: Life Long Liberal on the home page.

In Rudy Giuliani: Life Long Liberal, Rudy’s own words, news reports and commentary from both the left and right are utilized to prove that contrary to what we’ve been hearing and reading, Rudy Giuliani is what he has always been — a liberal.  It is’s hope that after reviewing the subject matter in the white paper, conservatives will take stories of Giuliani’s Damascus Road-like conversion with a grain of salt.